InspectAPedia TM |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| InspectAPedia Home |
| | Air Conditioning |
| | Electrical | | | Environment | | | Exteriors | | | Heating | | | Home Inspection |
| | Insulate Ventilate |
| | Interiors | | | Mold Inspect/Test |
| | Plumbing Water Septic |
| | Roofing | | | Structure | | | Contact Us |
|
HOW TO CLEAN MOLDY FRAMING & PLYWOOD 1. CLEAN MOLDY SURFACE CLEANING SMOOTH WOOD CLEANING IRREGULAR SURFACES - MEDIA BLASTING CLEANING MOLDY WOOD TRUSSES SANDING WOOD TO REMOVE MOLD 2. DRY THE SURFACE 3. TREAT & SEAL ADVANTAGES WARNINGS SOURCES & TYPES 4. CLEANING MISTAKES CROSS CONTAMINATION USING BLEACH USING OZONE PREVENT FUTURE MOLD COSMETIC MOLDS 5. CLEANUP LIMITATIONS More Information InspectAPedia TM Home & Site Map Air Conditioning InspectAPedia Bookstore Electrical Environment Exteriors Heating Home Inspection Insulate Ventilate Interiors Mold Inspect/Test Plumbing Water Septic Roofing Structure Accuracy & Bias Pledge Contact Us |
How to Clean Mold on Building Framing Lumber or Plywood Sheathing and Use of Fungicidal Sealants on Wood Building Materials
|
|
This article offers advice on cleaning mold found on surfaces of un-finished wooden building materials such as framing lumber (rafters, floor joists, wall studs), and building roof, wall, and floor sheathing such as plywood, tongue-and groove pine boards, and other structural wood surfaces in buildings. We discuss the pros and cons of using fungicidal sealants and bleach on wood surfaces and give sources and list types of those products. We also discuss common errors made when cleaning wood surfaces, such as relying on bleach or performing expensive and unnecessary cleaning on cosmetic black mold on wood surfaces. We include photographs of surfaces which have been cleaned during a good mold remediation project, and we provide photos of the effects of use of fungicidal sealants as encapsulants, particle immobilizers, and clear (or pigmented) surface sealants. © Copyright 2008 Daniel Friedman, All Rights Reserved. Information Accuracy & Bias Pledge is at below-left. Use the links at page left to navigate this document or to go to Other Resources.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Perfectly adequate cleaning may be accomplished by wiping or (where feasible) power-washing or media blasting. Where wiping a moldy surface, take care not to spread moldy debris from a moldy surface onto a previously uncontaminated surface by making the mistake of re-using the same moldy rag over and over on all surfaces. Professionals use "steri-wiping" which takes care to avoid spreading moldy debris by always folding and using a clean side of the wipe when moving to a new spot.
Where the framing lumber is indoors or otherwise in a location where water spillage is a concern, wipe the areas of heaviest mold to remove any loose mold from the surface of the lumber. Unless professional area-containment has been set up (barriers, negative air), do not use violent cleaning methods such as power-washing or sandblasting indoors, as you will spread moldy debris throughout the building and you'll increase the ultimate project cleanup cost. (Where the framing lumber is outdoors where water spillage and the creation of aerosolized mold spores is not an issue, pressure wash the infected lumber to remove surface mold.
"Cleaning" in this case can be simply wiping with a sponge wet with water or detergent. See my warnings below about using bleach. The object of cleaning is to remove most of the loose moldy particles. The object (except in medical facilities) is not to produce a particle-free sterile surface. However beware of cross-contamination. Wetting a rag and wiping a very moldy surface off is fine but if you then use the same dirty rag to wipe another fairly clean surface you may be in fact spreading moldy debris around. A professional uses sterile wipes and folds to a clean side of the wipe for each wiping stroke. For a small homeowner non-critical project this may be overkill but think about and avoid spreading moldy debris by your cleaning procedure.
If mold needs to be removed from a roof deck through which roofing nails penetrate, hand wiping is not feasible. Power cleaning using spray equipment such as media blasting using baking soda or dry ice is very effective for these surfaces. (See our media blasting article at "More Reading" below).
However spraying anything in an attic creates a secondary problem: contamination of building insulation. Our experience is that if attic conditions have been wet enough to produce problem mold justifying a professional cleaning of those surfaces, the insulation is probably contaminated and needs to be replaced.
Unless a building is being totally gutted to its framing, power-washing with water or any other liquid is problematic in a building attic where the procedure risks leaks into and wetting contents of the building below the work area. Dry-process spray cleaning works well in these areas. Typical high pressure sprays use baking soda or frozen C02, followed by HEPA vacuuming of the work area and probably of other building areas.
More Reading on methods for cleaning mold from difficult to access areas or removing mold from irregular building surfaces:
Mold Removal by Media Blasting - A test report (complete article, with illustrations) on the effectiveness of baking soda media blasting for cleaning fungal contamination in buildings, Daniel Friedman, Dennis Melandro, originally published in Indoor Environment Connections, Rockville MD, June 2003
In an area of high levels of mold growth or moldy dust and debris, the irregular surfaces formed by wood trusses and also by older wood cross bracing between floor joists prevents thorough cleaning of surfaces and creates many dust collection points.
A similar construction detail where significant moldy dust reservoirs may be left in place is the upper surface of wood furring which has been nailed across the under-side of floor joists to support (now removed) ceiling tiles.
Because the surfaces formed by trusses and cross bracing can form a significant dust and debris reservoir, I always check these areas during a mold remediation clearance inspection. If work has been hasty or incomplete, these are among the first areas to be under-cleaned.
Spray process cleaning and HEPA vacuuming are effective for these areas.
I often see remediators attempting to clean up mold by sanding surfaces, by hand or by power sander.
Sanding wood surfaces to remove mold is physically possible for smooth surfaces but in our opinion this is a slow, labor intensive procedure which is impractical for any large area cleanup. Spray processes are significantly faster and more thorough.
Sanding by hand is 1.) probably completely unnecessary and 2.) may indicate inexperience or a response to an improperly informed and frightened building owner. Clean the surface mold, dry the building, and if you like, use a sealant as discussed below. The fungal material left inside of wood framing or sheathing and which forms visible stains is not going to affect building occupants provided the building is kept properly dry and free of leaks. Even if you removed all of the stain by deep sanding, future building leaks will still \ produce new mold growth, so sanding is in most cases a wasted effort.
An exception I make to this general advice is where exposed beams are cleaned or sanded for cosmetic reasons. Still in that case media blasting cleans better and faster.
More Reading:
Mold Levels: allergenic or toxic mold: how much means a problem
Mold Removal by Media Blasting - A test report (complete article, with illustrations) on the effectiveness of baking soda media blasting for cleaning fungal contamination in buildings, Daniel Friedman, Dennis Melandro, originally published in Indoor Environment Connections, Rockville MD, June 2003
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Let the cleaned lumber or plywood surface dry thoroughly.
When lumber surfaces have been washed or otherwise are wet, they should be dry (less than 18% moisture content) before further treatment.
For wood framing and sheathing surfaces which have been cleaned of problem mold, a simple contact probe system or Tramex moisture encounter system is adequate since wood surfaces are directly accessible. In more broad investigations we measure moisture in wood and drywall using either a pin-probe type moisture meter such as the Delmhorst(TM) model BD-7, the Tramex Compact(TM) or for impenetrable surfaces such as tiled walls and floors we use the Tramex moisture encounter which uses a pair of pads and an electrical signal to perform non-destructive moisture detection. The Delmhorst also offers sets of long pin probes which can penetrate a wood frame wall or ceiling to sense moisture within insulation or on the far side of that cavity. We also use the Exergen infra-red scanner to find moisture based on variations in temperature. (A study comparing the effectiveness of various moisture measuring tools in the detection of moisture in inaccessible building cavities and a comparison of use of these instruments, a bore scope, and direct visual inspection by test cuts has been completed and is in process of being added to this website.)
Remember when measuring moisture that looking only in the center of a surface, such as 4 ft. up a drywall-covered partition, is not the full story. :Moisture may still be present at problem levels in slow-to dry areas including building wall and ceiling cavities and on drywall behind wood trim. Measure at the locations most-likely to still be wet, not the locations most-likely to be dry, if you're trying to avoid an indoor mold problem.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Optionally, you may elect to treat cleaned lumber by coating its surfaces with a sealant intended for that purpose and following the recommendations of the manufacturer.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Here are some advantages of using a fungicidal sealant following mold remediation
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
We have no financial interest in any of these products. This data was discovered by internet search. We have no scientific data as yet regarding the effectiveness, toxicity, chemical composition, nor durability of these products. We do not recommend using thick plaster or cementious coatings as these are more likely to later crack or leak, trapping moisture inside against the wood and promoting worse mold growth.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
This discussion lists common mold remediation or mold cleanup errors specific to attempts to clean mold from contaminated framing lumber or building sheathing such as plywood or pine boards used for subfloors or roofs. Inadequate cleaning and cross contamination are the two most common mistakes we find when inspecting and testing sites to perform a post remediation clearance for mold cleanup. Using bleaches, sprays, or ozone instead of cleaning are close behind in frequency of mistakes. Other mold remediation errors such as performing only demolition and failing to clean up the dust and debris caused by that step, are important but are not discussed in this moldy wood cleaning document.
Mold Cleanup Workmanship, Procedures, & Asbestos: But before discussing these (below) we add that you should be alert for other building contaminants that might need attention and which can be most-economically addressed by combining them into the mold remediation project. A common example is the discovery of asbestos pipe or surface insulation in a building which because of its location or condition needs to be encapsulated or removed. Since the technology for mold remediation involves similar containment and cleaning standards, if you have an asbestos problem at a different area on a moldy building you should discuss adding that work to the job. If asbestos materials are in the mold-remediation area and will be disturbed by the mold cleanup process, removing and cleaning this material will probably be unavoidable and will, unfortunately, add to the cost of the job.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Protect the areas outside or around the one being cleaned from mold contaminationby following published mold remediation guidelines such as the NY City Mold Cleanup guidelines. For large products (more than 30 sq.ft. of contaminated contiguous surface), the procedure involves tenting or sealing off the work area using plastic barriers, combined with establishing negative air pressure inside the work area so that particles and dust do not tend to escape the work area.
It is important that you protect workers performing remediation using appropriate masks, clothing, etc. Occupants, particularly people at extra risk of mold-related illness should not perform nor be present during this work.
Don't spray or power-wash moldy wood or other moldy surfaces without proper containment as you may be simply spreading mold spores around the indoor environment where you will infect other materials.
Small work projects (less than 30 sq.ft.) can normally be handled as a simple building cleaning or renovation project. But during a "small project" you should remain alert for the discovery of a previously unrecognized large area of contaminated materials. If the small project discovers that it has become a large one, work should stop to permit set-up of proper dust and particle containment.
More Reading:
Mold Remediation & Cleanup Standards
Mold Levels: allergenic or toxic mold: how much means a problem
Mold Cleaning, Remediation, & Clearance Testing Standards list of documents
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Bleach, diluted bleach, or bleach sprays used in cleaning may be appealing but they are unnecessary, potentially dangerous (if you get bleach in your eyes), and the use of bleach tends to lead to improper and inadequate cleaning - if you substitute "spraying bleach" for actually cleaning or removing the mold your cleanup will not be successful.
The object of mold remediation is to clean, or remove, the majority of the mold particles (spores, conidiophores, hyphae, mycelia) from the target surface. The operative word to fix in mind is to "clean" or "remove" the problem mold. "Killing" the mold is not the object - first of all because my lab work shows that you're unlikely to kill all of the mold on a surface using bleach, unless you use it at a concentration and duration which is so strong that you're likely to completely destroy the "bleached" material, and second of all because even if you could "kill" every mold spore, you are at risk of leaving toxic or allergenic particles in place - they may be dead but still toxic.
Finally, "mold removal" only works if you're cleaning a relatively hard, non-porous surface such as finished wood, painted metal, or plastic. Soft materials like Sheetrock(TM) or drywall which have become moldy generally should be removed, the exposed surfaces cleaned, and then new drywall can be installed (after you've also corrected the reason for the mold growth in the first place).
Spraying anything if spraying of fungicides or sealants is to be used in place of actual cleaning or removal of mold is an improper and inadequate practice which risks leaving a reservoir of toxic or allergenic particles in the building.
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Ozone Generators are another futile attempt to "kill" mold instead of cleaning it up. This "magic bullet" approach does not work and can destroy some building materials as well as the health of building occupants. Because of the trouble and cost of performing an effective mold cleanup in buildings, some vendors offer what sounds like an attractive alternative, offering to "kill all building mold" using ozone. One Midwest company offers to tent the building and follow a mold extermination procedure.
As with the "bleach" and other "kill the mold" approaches we described above, this process fails to remove the problem reservoir from the building, leaving toxic or allergenic particles. One of our clients, in an effort to remove odor and mold problems from their building, rented a commercial ozone generator ran it aggressively in closed rooms in their home. The ensuing odors, which we tested and traced to oxidized carpet padding, were so severe that the building was no longer habitable. Carpeting had to be removed as well as other oxidized rubber and foam products which had been "ozone treated." Worse, the underlying cause of the original complaint, which we traced to a history of flooding basement and wet building materials there, had gone unrecognized and still needed to be addressed.
There are valid applications of ozone as a disinfectant but it is not a valid treatment for mold in buildings.
More Reading:
The Use of Ozone Generators Indoors for Control of Odors and Mold Removal in Buildings: A Summary of Hazards and False Claims
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Following a proper mold cleanup, if there is a future mold problem in a building it is unlikely to be due to having left behind an "inoculation" of problem mold. The standard for physical removal of moldy debris varies by material. For drywall we remove all visibly moldy material and continue removing drywall to no less than the next adjacent stud, rafter, or joist. For insulation which has been wet, we remove all suspect insulation and all insulation within 24" of the suspect material. However if moldy and wet conditions were long-standing in a building, removal of all of the insulation may be necessary. Generally it is less costly to remove and discard more material than to "finish" the job and then discover that it needs to be done over again because the initial work was insufficient.
No washing, sanding, scraping, or other surface cleaning will remove all mold spores from wood where mold was previously found. It is unlikely that most construction materials, even when new, are free of mold spores, nor is "zero mold" a reasonable nor possible objective. Cleaning moldy framing lumber followed by application of a sealant may be the most cost effective alternative (where removal of the lumber is cost-prohibitive or otherwise not possible). While lumber replacement with apparently "clean" new lumber may sound appealing, it is likely to be cost prohibitive and in fact may include its own mold when it is unloaded at the work site.
Unless framing lumber has been actually damaged, such as by rot, replacing it due to mold contamination is not justified and would be improper.
Prevention of water leaks or excess humidity in building interiors, including wall and floor cavities, is critical if you want to avoid a mold growth problem in a building. Even following the most thorough mold remediation, future roof, plumbing, or cooling condensate leaks or any other source of water entry all risk future mold growth and related cosmetic, structural, health problems and economic costs.
More Reading:
What indoor humidity should we maintain in order to avoid a mold problem?
MOLD PREVENTION GUIDE: Correct the Causes of Mold and Prevent Indoor Mold or other indoor environment problems
Mold Prevention: Avoiding Mold Problems in Buildings by Using Mold-resistant Construction Products & Practices
Priorities for Preventing Indoor Mold Contamination in Buildings - responding to leaks and floods
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
It's important to distinguish cosmetic Ceratocystis, blue stain mold, blue rot, from other problem molds which in fact might be "toxic black mold" such as Stachybotrys chartarum or harder to spot but often more problematic molds in buildings such as the Penicillium sp. and Aspergillus sp. families of molds. One of our clients had begun a $600,000. "mold remediation" project on their home. A careful investigation of the property found that all of the "black mold" which had frightened the owners and which had resulted in this expensive cleaning contract, was cosmetic "blue stain" mold which had been present on the lumber since the day of construction of the building. The mold was of no concern other than a cosmetic one. Other clients occasionally send "not mold" samples to our laboratory.
To be sure you're not incurring a big and unnecessary expense, be sure that the "mold" to be addressed is really mold, and further, that it's not just a cosmetic mold, read the articles below before undertaking a costly mold remediation project.
More Reading:
Stuff that is Not Mold,
Molds that are Harmless - Cosmetic
Mold Levels: allergenic or toxic mold: how much means a problem
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
The suggestions for mold cleanup of wood surfaces which are outlined below do not pertain to
These suggestions have not completed an extensive professional peer review - which is why they are being exposed here to invite commentary. Comments received so far indicate this is reasonable commonsense advice.
Some mold found on wood components in building interiors is likely to be of only cosmetic concern, such as Ceratocystis/Ophistoma sp. or "blue stain" molds. Others may be more of a concern, particularly to occupants who are at particular risk of certain illnesses or immune system problems. Allergenic/pathogenic molds often identified on construction materials exposed indoors include Penicillium sp., Aspergillus sp., Stachybotrys chartarum (previously Stachybotrys atra), and numerous other species.
Depending in part on the particular species, the presence of mold growing on building materials risks contamination in the living environment and possible mold-related illnesses. This is true regardless of whether mold spores are merely allergenic (allergenic mold) or actually toxic (pathogenic mold) to humans, and regardless of whether or not mold spores present are viable (alive) or non-viable (dead). Where there is a concern regarding mold on building framing the following steps should be helpful at reducing the risk of future mold growth and therefore should reduce the chances of the subject mold will be the source of a future mold problem in the building:
Use links at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
More expert information on this topic
InspectAPedia TM Home & Site Map - Building Inspection, Diagnosis, & Repair, Environmental Inspection & Testing - Research Website
The Mold Information Center: What to Do About Mold in Buildings, When and How
to Inspect for Mold, Clean Up Mold, or Avoid Mold Problems
Home Inspection Construction Consulting Services & advice for home buyers
Use this simple, economical mold test kit by following
our instructions on how to collect and mail mold samples to our lab
Environmental
Inspection, Testing, & Diagnosis On-Site IAQ, Gas, Air Testing, Mold Investigation, Sick Building Diagnosis,
Lab Services, & Remediation Plan Preparation - indoor air quality testing, problem source determination, supporting lab work, written remediation plan addressing
removal of environmental and other hazards and prevention of their recurrence.
Contact Daniel Friedman for website content suggestions or for fee-paid consulting
08/15/2007 - 10/01/01 www.inspect-ny.com/sickhouse/cleanmold1.htm © Daniel Friedman 2006 2001 all rights reserved